Skip to content Skip to navigation

China Rejects UN Recommendations for Substantive Reform to Advance Human Rights; HRIC Summary

February 11, 2009

In the report of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of China issued by the UPR Working Group this morning, while accepting some recommendations on the promotion of human rights in general, China rejected many of the recommendations made by UN member states to implement specific measures and reforms to advance genuine human rights in China. The rejected recommendations include measures that would: provide freedom of information and expression; ensure the independence of the judiciary and lawyers; safeguard detainees’ access to counsel; protect lawyers from attacks and harassment; and grant freedom of religion and movement to ethnic minorities such as Tibetans and Uyghurs.

In a glaring act, China not only rejected recommendations to protect human rights defenders, but in fact accepted a recommendation by Cuba to target “people who are qualifying themselves as human rights defenders with the objective of attacking the interests of [the] state and the people of China.”

China also repudiated the work of the UN Committee Against Torture by rejecting a recommendation to implement the measures set forth by the Committee after its November 2008 review of China, particularly on the inadmissibility in court of statements made under torture.

“As a test of a state-driven process aimed at advancing human rights among member states through constructive dialogue, consensus decision-making, and cooperation, the Universal Periodic Review, with regard to China, is a failure,” said Sharon Hom, Executive Director of Human Rights in China. “Instead, the process has given China a ‘cover’ for impunity.”

Below are some examples of the recommendations that China rejected:

Rule of Law - Recommendations Rejected by China

Right to counsel & due process: Ensure every detainee has the right to regularly see visitors and has permanent access to legal counsel.

Judicial independence: Ensure independence of the judiciary and lawyers.

State secrets system: Reform the State Secrets law, and definitions of crimes as incitement to subversion of state power (which are abused vis human rights defenders).

Protection of rights defenders: Investigate reports of harassment and detention of human rights defenders, including alleged mistreatment while in police custody, with a view to ending impunity.

Administrative detention: Abolish administrative detention and forced labor without proper trial.

Death penalty: Provide statistics on number of death sentences.

Freedom of Information and Expression – Recommendations Rejected by China
Extend the media regulations that relaxed restrictions on foreign journalists reporting in China to domestic journalists; release all persons held on the basis of expression.

Cooperation with UN Procedures and Mechanisms – Recommendations Rejected by China
Take immediate measures to implement the recommendations of November 2008 of the Committee Against Torture, particularly on the inadmissibility in court of statements made under torture.

Rights of Ethnic Minorities and Freedom of Religion - Recommendations Rejected by China
Review laws and practices on freedom of religion, movement, protection of culture and language, including those of Tibetans and Uyghurs; investigate all cases in Tibet of police brutality and torture; ensure protection in Tibet of the right of peaceful assembly and release persons arrested for such assembly; resume dialogue regarding Tibet.

HRIC provides four charts that track UPR recommendations:

Summary Chart of Rejected UPR Recommendations [PDF, 45K]

Summary Chart of Accepted UPR Recommendations [PDF, 42K]

Summary Chart of UPR Recommendations Already Implemented [PDF, 18K]

Summary Chart of UPR Recommendations to Be Examined [PDF, 20K]

For more information on China's Universal Periodic Review and related UN work, see:

Explore Topics

709 Crackdown Access to Information Access to Justice Administrative Detention All about law Arbitrary Detention
Asset Transparency Bilateral Dialogue Black Jail Book Review Business And Human Rights Censorship
Charter 08 Children Chinese Law Circumvention technology Citizen Activism Citizen Journalists
Citizen Participation Civil Society Commentary Communist Party Of China Constitution Consumer Safety
Contending views Corruption Counterterrorism Courageous Voices Cultural Revolution Culture Matters
Current affairs Cyber Security Daily Challenges Democratic And Political Reform Demolition And Relocation  Dissidents
Education Elections Enforced Disappearance Environment Ethnic Minorities EU-China
Family Planning Farmers Freedom of Association Freedom of Expression Freedom of Press Freedom of Religion
Government Accountability Government regulation Government transparency Hong Kong House Arrest HRIC Translation
Hukou Human Rights Council Human rights developments Illegal Search And Detention Inciting Subversion Of State Power Information Control 
Information technology Information, Communications, Technology (ICT) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) International Human Rights International perspective International Relations
Internet Internet Governance JIansanjiang lawyers' rights defense Judicial Reform June Fourth Kidnapping
Labor Camps Labor Rights Land, Property, Housing Lawyer's rights Lawyers Legal System
Letters from the Mainland Major Event (Environment, Food Safety, Accident, etc.) Mao Zedong Microblogs (Weibo) National People's Congress (NPC) New Citizens Movement
Non-Governmental Organization (NGO) Olympics One country, two systems Online Activism Open Government Information Personal stories
Police Brutality Political commentary Political Prisoner Politics Prisoner Of Conscience Probing history
Propaganda Protests And Petitions Public Appeal Public Security Racial Discrimination Reeducation-Through-Labor
Rights Defenders Rights Defense Rule Of Law Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) Special Topic State compensation
State Secrets State Security Subversion Of State Power Surveillance Technology Thoughts/Theories
Tiananmen Mothers Tibet Torture Typical cases United Nations US-China 
Uyghurs, Uighurs Vulnerable Groups Women Youth Youth Perspective